The 2026 Northwestern Essays #12--In Praise of the Upper Midwest, and My Wife

The great ship that is Northwestern Football (6-4) finds itself traveling to Minnesota (5-5) to try to break a three game losing streak.  The game is yet another noon Eastern start and will be broadcast on FS1.  Last week was a tough game against Ohio State.  Neither team played particularly well, with both teams were playing with their backup quarterback.  But Ohio State has the best wide receiver in college football in Jeremiah Smith and Northwestern does not, and that really was the difference in the game (that and a very unfortunately muffed punt by NU early in the 4th quarter).  The final score was 28-19, and that's about right.  Disappointing, but not surprising or a crisis to be mourned.

Minnesota, as always, is an enigmatic team.  They beat Michigan for the first time in a while, but Michigan seems to be a bit of a leaking ship.  They beat Iowa in the most iconic Bad Iowa game I have ever seen.  I watched a big chunk of that game in an airport bar waiting for my flight, and it was so unwatchable that it became glorious and thoroughly entertaining.  They then gave Indiana a tough game, gave UCLA half of a tough game, and got smoked by Penn State last week.  They also got blown out by a bad Purdue team.  So, as usual, who's to say what you will get with Minnesota?  

I love Minnesota, the place.  When I was looking at law schools many moons ago, I applied to and was admitted to the University of Minnesota Law School, and was very close to going there.  I went to the admitted students' weekend in the middle of March and had a very enjoyable time.  The only red flag--the Twin Cities got 10 inches of snow on the Friday evening I was there.  To be fair, this provided a very accurate and truthful picture of the experience I would have had going to the University of Minnesota Law School.  I ended up getting into Penn late in the admissions cycle, but I have very found memories of my first trip to Minnesota.  I have since been back to the state a couple more times recently, as part of my trips to the greater Upper Midwest.

You see, my wife is from western Wisconsin, about two hours from the Twin Cities by car.  After trying a couple of different travel plans, the easiest way (not to say *easy*) to get there is to fly into the Twin Cities and drive or take Amtrak.  So, I have had a significant infusion of the Upper Midwest over the course of the last five years.  A month ago, we flew into the Twin Cities and drove to the old homeland for a family wedding, stopping at the Mall of America before we flew back home.  We had a blast.

My wife grew up in a place that literally is not officially a place--Humbird, Wisconsin.  It is unincorporated, with a population of three digits starting with a 1.  My favorite Humbird factoid is that there is a fairly well known cheese brand, Humbird Cheese, that was once manufactured in Humbird but has not been for some time.  But because the new owners could not surrender the brand cache that is Humbird so they kept the name.  After my wife left home, her parents moved to the Big City of Black River Falls, an overwhelming urban sprawl of about 3500 people that is the county seat of Jackson County, Wisconsin.  

A source of endless delight for me about my wife is that she is absolutely a Wisconsin farm girl, but she is also this sophisticated artist, as she is a trained opera singer.  And she is not half of each, but 100% of both.  I have seen her express pure joy singing Italian arias on the stage, and I have seen similar pure joy from her while wandering through the aisles at Lowe's looking at bathroom fixtures.  While she would not attribute any of the opera stuff to where she comes from, the other piece is purely a product of the Upper Midwest, and it is a big part of why I fell in love with her.  There is an unaffected practicality about my wife, a groundedness that I deeply appreciate.  I associate that with where she comes from.

I did not grow up around farms and farming; I am a child of the suburbs, through and through.  Going to visit her family is like stepping into another world for me.  Again, her parents have moved to what is basically a small town, but across the street from where my wife grew up is the farm where, among other things, they raise goats.  Goats.  If you told me they manufactured GPUs in their backyard that would be less exotic to me.

One of my favorite stories from my time as the husband of a Wisconsin girl is from a couple of years ago.  We were visiting Wisconsin over Labor Day weekend, and on Sunday we went to church--a tiny Lutheran church with an average Sunday attendance of around 30 people.  Prior to the service, the parish council president stood up to make an announcement.  As a sidebar, he had an accent that, had an actor being doing it in a movie or TV show, would be rejected as being way too over-the-top.  My wife tells me that farmers in her area, because they don't really associate with that many other people, develop their own family accents (a PhD dissertation about which I would definitely read).  In any event, the issue he was raising was about giving some money to another, nearby Lutheran parish on some anniversary of their founding.  This was presented in a manner that made it abundantly clear that this was a very controversial, fraught issue in this particular community.

Naturally, there was a story here that I needed to hear.  Why is there bad blood between two tiny Lutheran parishes in Jackson County, Wisconsin?  I asked my mother-in-law and my father-in-law, and they both told me that at one point in time the parishes shared a pastor, but the other parish broke away to get their own, separate pastor.  This of course raised a follow-up question--what made them break away?  To which I received vague, non-answer answers.  In other contexts, I would have interpreted this as attempting to suppress some dark secret.  But in the context of this place and these people, it was clear--no one remembered what happened.  My wife jokes that the source of the beef was that someone got mad about potato salad served at a parish picnic, but I think that very well may be true.

The whole thing was like a sketch from A Prairie Home Companion.  I listened to that show from time to time and thought it was funny, but now that show takes on a whole new context, because it has become clear to me that all of that material is basically true.  Without trying, the folks I have met from the Upper Midwest are really funny.  I feel a little bad saying this because I worry that they will think I am laughing at them, but I don't mean it that way.  But they are really funny, made more so because they are not trying to be funny.  I very much enjoy visiting Wisconsin and her family.

As I mentioned, we stopped at the Mall of America on our last trip to the area.  I understand that a particular mentality is required to enjoy the Mall of America, and that not everyone has that mentality.  I don't want to say that people think they are too cool or sophisticated for the Mall of America, but I also am not not saying that.  All I can say is that I am not too cool to have enjoyed my time at the Mall of America.  Upon reflection, I think a place like the Mall of America really can only exist in the Upper Midwest, because I think in any other location a project like this would be far too self-conscious.  It would be trying to convince you it was sophisticated or upscale or otherwise portray some particular image or brand position.  The Mall of America is just a really, really, really big Mall, and that's what makes it awesome.  It isn't trying to do anything other than be the most Mall possible.

I think that, ultimately, is what I like so much about this area.  I have never experienced a place that is less trying to convince you of something about itself.  The South, the Mountain West, the West, the Northeast, even Ohio--these are ideas that the people that live there are trying to project.  All of those places are self-conscious.  Minnesota and Wisconsin just kinda of are what they are.  And that's really a nice change, at least for me.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Holy Sex!--Part 3.3 Getting Down to Business, Part II

Holy Sex!--Part 3.2. Getting Down to Business, Part I

Another Theology of the Body, Part VI--A Theological Exploration of the Clitoris