New York, New York

There is nothing more inside baseball than the goings-on of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.  While the Bishop's Conference is a vehicle for the U.S. Bishops to speak with a unified voice, it's more like the Chamber of Commerce than a legislature--it can't really tell the individual Bishops what to do.

Still, I think it is relevant that today the Bishops elected Archbishop Timothy Dolan of New York as the President of the Conference.  This is surprising because the standard practice is for the Vice-President of the Conference to move up to the top spot as a pro forma matter after the sitting President finishes his 3 year term.  Dolan, however, defeated the Vice President, Bishop Gerald Kicanas of Tucson. 

Dolan, formerly the Archbishop of Milwaukee, made himself known in the broader world recently by feuding, via his blog, with the New York Times over some positive reviews of a play about nuns that Dolan thought was anti-Catholic.  The fight continued when the Times didn't publish an op-ed Dolan wrote calling out what he believed was a selected focus on Catholic sexual abuse, as opposed to other incidents of sexual abuse, in the Times (The Times responded here, defending its reporting).  I think it would be fair to say that Dolan represents a confrontational tone and attitude toward the secular world, and that his unprecedented election is an endorsement of that approach by the rest of the Bishops.

The new Vice President is Archbishop Joseph Kurtz of Louisville, who heads up the USCCB's efforts against gay marriage.  Again, hard not to interpret that as a statement of commitment to holding the line on the culture wars issues.

The AP story had two additional elements that I thought were interesting.  Robert George, the Princeton University scholar and (I've noticed) recent go-to guy for a conservative Catholic quote, mentions that Dolan has a good track record of "working with people of other faiths" (read: evangelicals, and maybe Mormons depending on the context).  Dolan signed on to the recent Manhattan Declaration (which can be seen here) spearheaded by George and Chuck Colson to bring together conservative Christians of various denominations around the culture war issues.  Expect more of this type of thing in the future.

Second, there is a mention in the article about a campaign by unnamed conservative Catholic bloggers against Bishop Kicanas.  A quick Google search turned up this story and this story.  The Tim Drake story at the National Catholic Register seems to focus on Bishop Kicanas's involvement in a sexual abuse case in Chicago when he was rector of the Seminary (though the Archbishop of Chicago during the same case, Cardinal George, just ended his term as President), but the other story, while mentioning the abuse issue, seems to focus on Bishop Kicanas's supposed liberalism.  In any event, it is interesting that major news outlets are attributing a role to Catholic bloggers, who have been in the news of late.

I have no exposure to Archbishop Dolan other than what I've read.  I heard him two times come up to the booth of the Yankee radio broadcasts to schmooze with John Sterling and Suzyn Waldman, and he seemed to be a jovial guy (though, in fairness, Sterling and Waldman are so bad that any new person in the booth is an objective improvement).  The Manhattan Declaration stuff is troubling--I will probably write about this in the future, but I have serious concerns about associating closely with evangelical Protestants on anything, including (and in some cases, especially) on these culture war issues.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Another Theology of the Body, Part VI--A Theological Exploration of the Clitoris

I was introduced to The Body's Grace by Frank from Letters to the Catholic Right in this post , where he quotes Williams saying: It puts the question which is also raised for some kinds of moralist by the existence of the clitoris in women; something whose function is joy. If the creator were quite so instrumentalist in ‘his’ attitude to sexuality, these hints of prodigality and redundancy in the way the whole thing works might cause us to worry about whether he was, after all, in full rational control of it. But if God made us for joy…? I want to talk about the first part of that quote here, regarding the clitoris.  I am not aware of any theology that has been done on the clitoris, but there should be.  As Williams alludes to, the existence and nature of the clitoris is a theological "problem," especially if you want to hold on to traditional Christian sexual morality.  It is especially problematic if you want to hold that sexuality needs to be understood through the...
Read more

On a Pelagian Politics, and Why It Would Be Good

I have two very hot takes.  The first is that Joe Biden is the best United States President in my lifetime, and probably the best since Franklin Roosevelt, and his many critics on both the right and the left are wrong.  The second is that the Irish monk Pelagius and his (mostly Celtic) disciples were basically right, and more specifically Pelagius's great opponent Augustine (and by extension the rest of the Western Church ever since) was wrong.  But the hottest take, the Hegelian synthesis of this Hotness, is that these two takes are ultimately the same take.  I believe that Biden is a great President because I am a Pelagian with a Pelagian world view, whereas American politics is fundamentally Calvinist, which is just Augustinianism taken to its logical conclusion. Let me try to justify this ball of hot takes. 1. Most of what we know of Pelagius comes from his opponents, especially Augustine and Jerome, who attempted (more or less successfully) to have him cast out ...
Read more

A Reflection on the Past, and Also on Art

Exactly twenty-two years ago, in February of 2002, I was living in River Forest, Illinois, finishing up my undergraduate degree.  I was living in an enormous old priory, hoping that I would be able to join the Dominicans when I was done with school in the summer (which, in fact, happened).  The priory was built in the 50s, when the Dominicans would have classes of a fifty or sixty students a year.  Those days were long gone, and so I was the only person living on the hall, on the far other side of the building from the actual Dominicans.  Other than meals, I was basically living entirely by myself. In my evenings, after getting done with my homework, I had a ritual on weekdays.  I would turn on the radio to the Chicago rock radio station Q101 and listen to the syndicated show Loveline .  Loveline  was a call-in show, focused on giving sex and relationship advice to teenagers and twenty-somethings.  The hosts of the show were comedian Adam Corolla ...
Read more